Pastures for the Planet: Soil Health
Closeup of agronomy specialist taking soil sample in test tube outdoors.

Pastures for the Planet is also available on Spotify and Apple Podcasts. (Coming soon to Amazon Music!)

Jess [00:00:04:09] Hello and welcome to pastures for the planet, the podcast for equestrians who want to work with nature, not against it. I’m Jess Friedman of Friedman Family Farms, and I’m here with Alayne Blickle, creator and director of Horses for Clean Water, an environmental education program trusted by horse owners all over the world. Okay, Alayne, what are we going to talk about today?
 
Alayne [00:00:26:09] We’re going to talk about soil. But we’re going to switch roles a little bit, and I’m going to be the one asking you the questions. So, some of our audience might know you as the one who does the cool graphics and our website and our newsletter, but why don’t you share with all of us about your degree and your background?
 
Jess [00:00:50:14] So I have a Master’s in Organic Farming and Food Production Systems. It’s obviously not horse-related, but it did have a fair bit of overlap when it comes to pasture health. My thesis actually looked at the impacts of different soil fertility amendments on weed suppression and disease resistance in certain crops
 
Alayne [00:01:08:03] But you grew up with horses, right?
 
Jess [00:01:10:23] I did. I’ve been riding horses since I was about eight years old, and my favorite thing to do when I’m home in Idaho is to go out riding in the foothills with my mom. I’ve also worked with horses off and on. Over the years, I’ve managed a small herd of ponies at an ag program that I used to run. I’ve worked with dressage horses and reining horses and it’s my favorite thing. I absolutely love being around horses.
 
Alayne [00:01:38:05] That’s so awesome. Okay, so tell us, why is it important to talk about soil health with horse owners?
 
Jess [00:01:49:09] Healthy pastures start with healthy soil. If you want to have a good pasture for your horses, you have to make sure that the fundamentals are there for your soil to be healthy.
 
Alayne [00:01:57:23] And what do you mean by healthy soil?
 
Jess [00:02:00:23] Farmers often describe healthy soils as friable, which means it crumbles easily instead of forming those hard clods you see sometimes. This allows for deep root penetration, which makes it so that plants can access water and nutrients from a larger volume of soil. This makes them more resilient during dry periods, and it makes it so that your plants are a lot happier and healthier. And because healthy soils support larger root systems and more microbial activity, it allows more carbon to be stored underground, like we talked about in episode one.
 
They’re also well-drained, so water doesn’t sit on top, creating mud and suffocating your plant roots, and well-aerated instead of compacted. They contain a good balance of nutrients. Too little or too much of any nutrient will both cause plants to struggle, and can even increase weed and pest pressure.
 
Healthy soils can also help reduce weeds by making sure your desired plants have the water and nutrients they need to outcompete the plants you don’t want. Many weeds thrive in poor soils, but they can’t get established in healthy ecosystems.
 
But most importantly, healthy soils are home to a large number of organisms. Most of these are too small to see with the naked eye, but earthworms, beneficial insects, and fungi are good indicators of a healthy microbiome. These microorganisms play a critical role in nutrient cycling, or breaking down organic matter and converting it to the nutrients plants need to thrive. They also help with root development, disease suppression, and improving soil structure. 
 
Alayne, I’ve often heard that horses are harder on pastures and soil than other livestock like cows. Is that true?
 
Alayne [00:03:38:17] Well, they can be, but basically it comes down to management. Horses are what we call selective grazers. They have a highly developed sense of taste. And combining that with both upper and lower incisors allow horses to nip grasses as close to the ground as we let them. So left to their own devices, they’ll return to the same areas and same plants over and over and over again, nipping off that grass plant at the sweetest part of the plant, which is right at the base of the grass plant stem, right next to the ground.
 
Cattle, on the other hand, they don’t have upper incisors. They have what’s called a dental pad on the top and incisors on the bottom. And cattle prefer to use their tongue to grasp and tear the longer grass. So in this way, they tend not to over graze an area as much as a horses able to do. But the bottom line for any livestock, any animal that’s on pasture, is management.
 
And by and large, I think that cattle and cattle owners tend to start out with keeping their animals on larger pastures with longer grass than horses and horse owners do. Horse owners often don’t have a lot of pasture at their disposal, so horses start out with a smaller grazing area in most cases, and then that can quickly become overgrazed right down to the ground.
 
So overgrazed pastures can’t develop the root structures they need to keep the soil loose and healthy. Horses also tend to create a latrine area that we usually call the rough. And then that causes a heavy buildup of nutrients in one area. And then horses naturally avoid grazing in these areas, so the grass and weeds all grow there as tall as they want.
 
Jess [00:05:51:14] Interesting.
 
Alayne [00:05:52:13] Okay, Jess, so how do we know if the soil is healthy or not?
 
Jess [00:05:57:09] To assess your soil, you’ll want to look at five main characteristics: texture, drainage, compaction, nutrients, and pH. Texture is going to tell you more about the makeup of your soil. Soils are a mix of clay, silt, and sand. Clay particles act like magnets that hold on to essential nutrients, and their tiny pore spaces help it retain moisture. But too much clay in your soil can lead to compaction and poor drainage. Silt also helps hold onto nutrients, and because of its larger particle size, it helps the soil maintain more aeration than clay alone. But silt is also very lightweight, so too much silt in your soil can make it more prone to erosion. Sand’s large particle size helps reduce compaction, but too much sand in your soil can cause it to leach important nutrients.
 
What you’re looking for is what they call a loamy texture, which is roughly 40% sand, 40% silt, and 20% clay. We’ll put a link in the show notes to a really great resource from UC Davis that that’ll help you learn how to tell what kind of soil you have just by feeling it.
 
 
Alayne [00:07:04:03] So if I have a soil that’s leaning too far in one direction or another, what’s the best way to fix it?
 
Jess [00:07:11:21] Adding organic matter like composted horse manure can help no matter what type of soil you’re dealing with. Adding compost won’t change whether your soil is technically clay or sand, but it dramatically improves how those soils behave by improving aggregation, water holding capacity, drainage, and biological activity.
 
There’s also the option of adding bentonite or kaolin clay to sandy soil, or coarse sand to silty soil, but since pastures are generally a large area, it can be cost and labor intensive. Adding organic matter is much simpler, and it can go a long way towards bringing soil closer to that loamy ideal that we’re looking for.
 
Alayne [00:07:51:16] Okay. So next is drainage, right? How do we assess that?
 
Jess [00:07:57:19] A perc or percolation test is actually really simple to do. You’ll start by digging a hole about a foot deep and filling it with water. After that water has drained completely, you immediately refill the pit and measure the depth of the water with a ruler. You check it again after 15 minutes and see how much water is left in the hole. Then you multiply that difference by four to determine how much water drains in an hour. Ideal drainage is 1 to 6 inches per hour. Because pasture soils can vary from one spot to the next. Plan on repeating this test in a few different spots so you get a good feel for your entire area.
 
Alayne [00:08:34:00] Okay, so what do we do if the soil is poorly drained?
 
Jess [00:08:39:01] Once again, adding organic matter is the most effective long term solution for improving soil drainage. That organic matter is going to feed microorganisms in your soil, and they bind the soil into larger clumps that create more porosity. If an area has especially poor drainage, you might need to consider structural drainage systems like French drains or dry wells.
 
Poor drainage can also be an early indicator of soil compaction, but you can also check your compaction by pushing a long screwdriver into the ground. If you meet resistance after only 2 or 3 inches, your soil is likely compacted. You can use a ripper or a pasture aerator to break up dense subsoil layers or hard pans, as they call them, and open up the soil for air and water. But unfortunately, those tools can be pretty cost prohibitive for smaller landowners.
 
Alayne [00:09:29:12] Yeah. I remember seeing years ago a farm with a conservation district I worked for, they used a ripper to break up a pasture that had been super compacted. It was really cool what it did, but it is expensive to use and it’s a really invasive technique. If you need to do it, you need to do it. But that’s kind of a worst case scenario, I would say.
 
If you do need equipment, you might want to look at borrowing from a neighbor. I know we have, we have some of the best neighbors here. They have so many pieces of equipment. We are really grateful to be able to borrow from them occasionally. But you could also share implements between horse owners. That’s another great option that I encourage people to do. You can rent equipment from rental businesses, you can buy from agricultural auctions, and surprisingly, there’s a lot of those around, in most cases anyway. Do an internet search for local agricultural equipment auctions and see what comes up.
 
Okay, so next nutrients and pH. How do we assess the nutrient levels in our soils?
 
Jess [00:10:48:19] The best way to do that is with a soil test. Any hardware or gardening store will have simple test kits that you can do yourself, but they’re not always super accurate. They’ll give you a ballpark understanding of nutrient levels, but if you really want a complete picture, you can send a sample to a soil lab. This service is often provided for a reasonable cost by universities, extension agencies, conservation districts, or NRCS offices. And the advantage of getting your soil tested by a lab is that they’ll usually give you pretty specific recommendations for how to correct any nutrient imbalances they find in your soil.
 
Alayne [00:11:23:19] So when I teach pasture management classes, I really try to stress the importance of getting an accurate soil test before people apply anything. Don’t just go down to your feed store and ask the worker there, because they may not know anything about soil science and they certainly don’t know your soil. It’s going to be far better to get your soil tested by a lab, and then have someone who can help you understand the results.
 
So again, go back to your local conservation district or extension office and see if either of those offices can help you. And help can range from having someone there interpret the results for you, or they can possibly loan out equipment like a soil auger for getting a soil sample. Or some conservation districts will even provide cost sharing that can go towards the expense of getting the soil test done.
 
The most important thing to remember is that it’s not recommended to apply any sort of fertilizer to your pasture without first doing a soil test. Otherwise you could potentially be throwing away money, since whatever nutrients your plants can’t use are just going to get washed away. And that is the part that can cause a water pollution issue.
 
Jess [00:12:48:20] I know you’re really good about recommending soil tests to the people that you work with through Horses for Clean Water. What is your recommendation on frequency? How often do you recommend people test their pasture soil?
 
Alayne [00:13:00:13] I go with what conservation districts recommend, and usually they recommend retesting every five years. But you can also test anytime you start to see signs of a nutrient deficiency, like yellowing leaves at the height of growing season. That’s one indication.
 
Jess [00:13:19:03] Okay.
 
Alayne [00:13:19:20] So, Jess, what kind of nutrients do plants need?
 
Jess [00:13:23:15] Okay, so there are 17 essential nutrients needed for plant growth. But the three most important are nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. You’ll often see them abbreviated as NPK. Nitrogen is primarily responsible for green growth and the synthesis of proteins. Phosphorus is responsible for metabolic processes in plant cells, including photosynthesis, and for root growth and development. And potassium is essential for the movement of water within the plant.
 
In nature, phosphorus and potassium exist in mineral form, and there’s a lot of nitrogen in our atmosphere. Unfortunately, that nitrogen is in a form that plants can’t use. Certain bacteria convert atmospheric nitrogen into a bioavailable form in a process called nitrogen fixation, and other soil microbes recycle nitrogen by breaking down organic matter into plant available forms. And legumes like alfalfa work with rhizobia bacteria in their roots to naturally add nitrogen to the soil.
 
Alayne [00:14:22:20] Awesome. So if a pasure needs one or more of these nutrients, can’t we just apply a bunch of fertilizer and let nature sort it out?
 
Jess [00:14:33:08] Nope. When it comes to fertility, the rule of thumb is to apply the right type at the right rate in the right place and at the right time. The nice thing about owning horses is that composted horse manure is an excellent slow release fertilizer. I know you are really big on composting horse manure, so when do you recommend people spread their compost on their fields? 
 
Alayne [00:14:57:13] So yes, I’m really excited that it’s circling back to compost and composted horse manure. Late spring and any time in the fall are the best times to apply compost. That’s because grass plants are cool season plants, and they’re going to be growing best and able to utilize the compost best at those times of the year. And adding fertilizer in the spring just as things start to green up gives your soil a good boost for the growing season, and adding it in the fall allows it time to work in the into the soil over the winter.
 
What you absolutely don’t want to do is apply it to frozen or saturated soils, because all of those valuable nutrients will just end up getting washed away, and again, going back to causing water quality issues. 
 
So you mentioned pH. What kind of pH levels should we all be looking for?
 
Jess [00:16:02:17] A slightly acidic to neutral soil, so a pH of 6.0 to 6.5 will ensure that cool season pasture grasses, which most pasture grasses are, can absorb essential nutrients. If you grow a pasture mix that includes legumes like alfalfa, you might want to aim a little higher, like 6.5 to 7.
 
Alayne [00:16:23:08] And how do you suggest that people adjust their soil pH?
 
Jess [00:16:29:06] For overly acidic soils, you can add agricultural lime—either dolomitic lime if you also need magnesium or calcitic lime if you don’t. But it’s kind of complicated, so make sure that you talk to your extension office, your conservation district, or NRCS office for help with this so you get the right type and the right application.
 
Alayne [00:16:48:18] Yeah. And the Pacific Northwest is a good example of an area that often needs to have lime added to their soil. And you want to make sure that you have the right kind and the lime has been formulated in a way that you can utilize it. One example, Quick Climb Lime is a chemical lime that’s caustic and corrosive and can be dangerous to handle, so you don’t want to go that direction.
 
You want to make sure that you get some kind of crushed limestone, and usually you’re going to want it pelleted or prilled so that you can easily apply it, like with some type of a seed spreader like a drop seed spreader. So you want to get some a little bit of help with this so that you can get something that’s going to be useful and easy for you to apply.
 
Jess [00:17:45:18] And then on the other side of the spectrum, if you have overly alkaline soils, you can amend with elemental sulfur. But it’s a bit more complicated even than lime. So make sure that you enlist the help of your community extension office or conservation district to know how to apply it properly. Normally, either lime or sulfur would be tilled into the top 6 to 8 inches of soil. Bu tsince you don’t want to disturb your soil unless absolutely necessary, like you talked about earlier, you can add it as a top dressing.
 
It can take up to a year to see the full pH change, so don’t add more than the recommended amount hoping to get things to change quickly, or you actually risk pushing it too far in the wrong direction. 
 
Another thing that’s really important to keep in mind is that ingesting sulfur can cause colic or digestive distress, and inhaling lime dust can cause respiratory issues. So whether you’ve added lime or sulfur, it’s best to keep horses off the grass until you can no longer see the product. Applying it before rain or irrigation can help.
 
Okay, so after we’ve talked about all of this, what would you say is the biggest mistake horse owners make when trying to improve their pasture?
 
Alayne [00:18:51:14] The biggest mistake that I see is horse owners letting their pastures get overgrazed, which can dry out the soil because you don’t have all the grass there to shade it, it can compact the ground, it’s going to damage the soil health and then affect the productivity of the pasture plants. The other big mistake that I see is not composting and not utilizing all that free soil amendment that’s available to horse owners to use on their property.
 
Jess [00:19:25:10] And let’s say I can only do one thing to improve my pasture soil this year. What should it be?
 
Alayne [00:19:30:20] Super easy. And that is add compost. You can get help if you need it. Help is is so available, either again through your conservation district or extension or NRCS—or us, Horses for Clean Water. We can help you with figuring out where to put a compost system and how to set things up. But one of the horse owners that I worked with in the past said something to me that has totally stuck in my brain, and he said, there’s only one mistake that horse people can make with composting, and that is to not do it.
 
Jess [00:20:13:08] Mmm.
 
Alayne [00:20:13:18] So I say, let’s start utilizing all that free soil amendment that we’ve got available to us and start creating healthy pastures and healthy soils.
 
Jess [00:20:26:04] Great.
 
As of 2023, the American Horse Council estimates that there are 6.6 million horses in the United States alone. If even half of those horses were kept on one acre of good grassy pasture, there would be over 3 million acres of grass sequestering carbon, storing water, filtering pollutants and cooling temperatures. It’s easy to see how small management changes can make a significant environmental impact.
 
Over the course of this season, we’ll discuss sustainable pasture management practices in greater detail. Join us to learn how to set up and care for your pastures throughout the year, maximizing productivity, improving horse health, and acting as good stewards of the land instead of just users of it.
 
This podcast is produced by Horses for Clean Water. You can visit us at horsesforcleanwater.com, or follow us on Facebook and Instagram. If you have questions about sustainable horse keeping, send us a message on our Facebook page and we’ll consider it for a future episode. Thank you for joining us today, and until next time, happy riding!

Like this post? Sign up for our newsletter to get posts just like it sent right to your inbox, along with updates about special events. 

Related Posts

Pasture management. I think it’s one of the hardest things for horse owners to get their minds around. It doesn’t matter where I go—Idaho, Washington State, Australia—I think it’s the number one question horse owners have.

If your pasture pasture resembles a weed patch that turns into mud from the lightest rain, it's time to start practicing good pasture management. Here are some simple but impactful techniques to put into practice to transform that pasture into a lush paradise.
When it comes to climate change, many feel that things are beyond our control and that we are rocketing towards a new world of environmental change. While this is true in part, there are several simple practices we as horse owners can do to make a difference and help reduce the effects of climate change.